When I reviewed the Maybelline Color Tattoo 24 HR Cream Gel Eyeshadows, I compared them to the MUFE Aqua Creams and how the Aqua Creams paled in comparison to the Maybelline eyeshadows. I wanted to do a formal review to show just how it fares on my eyelids, especially since these are touted quite often as being crease proof, waterproof, and long lasting under extreme conditions.
When I quoted my wear time with the Aqua Cream as being around 6 hours before creasing, it had been a little while since I used it and I was quoting from memory. I thought I would put it through a 24 hour wear test to see how long it really lasted.
I only own one shade,#12 which is a vibrant copper. My experiment with the Aqua Cream may be related to the shade I got, but I don't know if I'd be willing to shell out $22 to find out.
And because I could, product photos first before my results!
Ignore the circular crack, my pot of Aqua Cream is a bit older so it doesn't look all pristine and new.
Onto the experiment results!
Here's the before. Ooh look at how bright and metallic looking it is. I tested this with no primer.

and the after after I tested it. For how long?
8 hours. Needless to say, a 24 hour wear test was not needed. I honestly don't know where it all went. I went to sleep wearing this and the Maybelline Color Tattoo Eyeshadow to test the wear time for both. When I woke up (and after 8 hours), this is what was left while the Maybelline Color Tattoo Eyeshadow was still holding on strong. If you look real closely, you can see what's left on the inner corner and the bit of residue in the folds on my lids.
I checked my fingers and checked my pillow to see if I had somehow rubbed off the Aqua Cream on there during the night, and I didn't see any residue. I really don't understand it.
$22 is a heavy price to pay for something that is supposed to be a crease proof and waterproof product. I really don't know why these didn't last long on me, especially since they seem to last forever for others but these are my results.
The moral of the story is that your mileage will vary when it comes to makeup. What works on me, may not work on you and what works on you may definitely not in the slightest way work on me. At least if I'm telling you to buy something, a $7 eyeshadow like the Maybelline Color Tattoo Eyeshadows won't hurt your wallet that badly.
Disclaimer: I purchased this with my own money, all opinions are my own.